A Short Comparison: Shaolin Virtues vs. Confucian Principles

Both Shaolin virtues and Confucian principles are guiding lights for ethical conduct, but they stem from different philosophical backgrounds.

Photo by Diana on Pexels.com

Shaolin Temple, far from just a martial arts school, is steeped in the rich tapestry of Buddhist philosophy and is considered the cradle of Chan (Zen) Buddhism in China.

This Buddhist foundation deeply influences and shapes the Four Virtues of Shaolin, offering a unique perspective compared to the Four Confucian Cardinal Principles that have long influenced Chinese culture.

Shaolin Buddhism: A Path to Enlightenment

Shaolin Buddhism follows the Chan (Zen) Buddhism school, which emerged from the Mahayana school of Buddhism. Mahayana emphasizes achieving Bodhu, the enlightenment for the benefit of all beings, not just oneself.

Established in the 5th century AD, the Shaolin Temple became a centre for both Buddhist practice and the development of Shaolin Kung Fu.

Philosophically, Shaolin Buddhism draws heavily from core Buddhist tenets like the Four Noble Truths (the nature of suffering, its cause, its cessation, and the path to its end) and the Eightfold Path (the right view, right intention, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration).

These principles guide practitioners towards self-awareness, overcoming desires, and achieving liberation from suffering.

Shaolin Kung Fu, while appearing at odds with Buddhist pacifism, is seen as a form of self-discipline and physical embodiment of the Eightfold Path. The rigorous training hones focus cultivates compassion by allowing one to defend others, and embodies the principle of right action by utilizing force only when necessary.

Confucianism: Harmony Through Order

Confucianism, arising in the 6th century BC, emphasizes social order, morality, and fulfilling one’s role within society. Founded by Kong Qiu – 孔丘, known in Western countries as Confucius (Kǒng Fūzǐ  – 孔夫子 or Master Kong), it emphasizes “Li” (propriety) – appropriate behaviour based on social hierarchies – and “Ren” (benevolence) – acting with compassion and consideration for others.

Confucianism established a social framework based on respect for elders, authority figures, and filial piety (devotion to one’s parents and ancestors). This cultural and philosophical framework aimed to create a harmonious and well-functioning society where everyone fulfills their appropriate role.

Historical Intertwining

Despite their philosophical differences, Shaolin Buddhism and Confucianism co-existed and influenced each other for centuries. Confucian values provided a social framework for Buddhist practice in China. For instance, the emphasis on order and respect for authority within Confucianism resonated with the monastic hierarchy of Shaolin.

Conversely, Buddhism offered a spiritual dimension to Confucian principles. The focus on self-improvement in Buddhism could be seen as complementing the Confucian emphasis on self-cultivation and moral development.

Shaolin itself exemplifies this synergy. Its emphasis on discipline and order reflects Confucian influences, while its focus on self-improvement and compassion aligns with Buddhist goals.

A comparison

Here’s a breakdown comparing the four Shaolin virtues with their closest corresponding Confucian principles:

Shaolin	Description	Confucianism	Description
Discipline (纪律 – Jìlǜ)	Refers to self-control, following established rules and routines in Shaolin training. It fosters perseverance and consistency.	Propriety (禮 – Lǐ)	Emphasizes appropriate behavior in social situations, respecting hierarchy and tradition. It promotes order and harmony.
Self-Improvement (⾃制 – Zìzhì)	Focuses on personal growth, constantly striving to become a better martial artist and individual. It encourages lifelong learning and self-reflection.	Righteousness (義 – Yì)	Acting in accordance with moral principles, even when difficult. It prioritizes doing the right thing over personal gain.
Modesty (謙虛 – Qiānxū)	Maintaining humility and acknowledging one’s limitations. It fosters respect for others and avoids arrogance.	Integrity (廉 – Lián)	Living with honesty and avoiding corruption. It emphasizes being trustworthy and fair in all dealings.
Compassion (慈悲 – Cíbēi)	Emphasizes kindness and understanding towards others, even opponents. It promotes a peaceful and harmonious approach.	Shame (恥 – Chǐ)	Recognizing and taking responsibility for one’s wrongdoings. It fosters self-awareness and a desire to learn from mistakes.

Key Differences

• Focus: Shaolin virtues are geared towards individual development within martial arts practice. Confucian principles, on the other hand, focus on social conduct and maintaining a harmonious and well-ordered society.
• Action vs. Inaction: Shaolin virtues like discipline and self-improvement require active pursuit of growth. Confucian principles like propriety and shame emphasize avoiding improper behaviour and maintaining order.
• Compassion: While both emphasize ethical behaviour, Shaolin specifically includes compassion, reflecting the Buddhist influences on the tradition.

Similarities

• Emphasis on Morality: Both Shaolin and Confucian traditions value ethical conduct and living a meaningful life.
• Importance of Self-Cultivation: Both prioritize personal development and becoming a better version of oneself.
• Respect for Hierarchy and Order: Both traditions value established structures and respect for one’s position within them.

In conclusion, the Shaolin virtues and Confucian principles complement each other. Shaolin virtues provide a framework for personal growth within a martial arts context, while Confucian principles offer guidance for ethical behavior in society. Understanding both fosters a well-rounded approach to living a meaningful and virtuous life.